GIA and IGI are the two labs whose names you'll see most on diamond listings. For natural diamonds they grade the same way, on the 4Cs. For lab-grown diamonds they no longer do: since 1 October 2025, GIA gives a lab-grown stone one of two ratings, Premium or Standard, instead of a color and clarity grade. IGI still grades lab-grown stones on the full 4Cs.
Neither report makes the stone better or worse. They tell you different amounts about it, and that changes how you compare prices. This page explains both, side by side.
What GIA changed in October 2025
GIA has graded lab-grown diamonds since 2007, and from 2020 it gave them the same color and clarity grades as natural diamonds, on digital-only reports. In 2025 it reversed course. Its reason, in the words of its president and CEO, Pritesh Patel: "Using descriptive terms for the quality of laboratory-grown diamonds is appropriate as most fall into a very narrow range of color and clarity." GIA put that range at more than 95% of the lab-grown diamonds entering the market.
Since 1 October 2025, each colorless to near-colorless lab-grown diamond GIA examines (0.15 carat and up) gets one of two assessments:
- Premium: D color, VVS clarity or better, Excellent polish and symmetry, and an Excellent cut grade on round brilliants.
- Standard: at least J color (E to J, or D when the stone misses another Premium criterion), at least VS clarity, Very Good polish, Very Good symmetry (Good on fancy shapes), and a Very Good cut grade on round brilliants.
A stone that misses any of the Standard minimums gets no GIA assessment. GIA's fee is US$15 per carat (minimum $15), a printed document comes back with each stone, and the girdle is laser-inscribed "Laboratory-Grown" with the assessment number. Reports GIA issued before the change remain valid, and colored lab-grown diamonds still get a separate GIA report.
In practice, that means a lab-grown stone with a GIA Premium or Standard assessment is at least J color and VS clarity, and a stone rated Premium is near the top of every scale. What the report no longer tells you is where in that range a Standard stone sits.
GIA and IGI side by side, for lab-grown
| On the report | GIA (since 1 Oct 2025) | IGI |
|---|---|---|
| Color | No letter grade. Premium needs D; Standard needs D to J (usually E to J: a D stone that misses another Premium bar is Standard) | Letter grade, D to Z |
| Clarity | No clarity grade. Premium needs VVS or better; Standard needs at least VS | Clarity grade, from flawless down |
| Cut (round brilliants) | Premium needs Excellent; Standard needs at least Very Good | Cut grade |
| Polish and symmetry | Premium needs Excellent; Standard needs at least Very Good (symmetry Good on fancy shapes) | Graded |
| Carat weight | Stated | Stated |
| Below the minimum | No GIA assessment at all | Graded on the same scale, however low |
| Marked as lab-grown | Yes; girdle laser-inscribed "Laboratory-Grown" and the assessment number | Yes; girdle inscribed "LAB GROWN" with the IGI report number |
| Growth method | Not one of the Premium/Standard criteria; GIA's announcement doesn't say whether the document states it | Stated (for example CVD), with any post-growth treatment |
IGI is also the lab most lab-grown stones go to. Its 2024 share-offering filing put its share of lab-grown grading reports at 65%, so most lab-grown listings with an exact color and clarity carry an IGI report. In December 2025, JCK described the two labs as having split exactly this way: GIA with "more general descriptors", IGI continuing "to offer full 4Cs grading".
Comparing two lab-grown stones
Price follows the grades, so the report decides how precisely you can compare:
- Two IGI stones: compare grade for grade, as you would with natural diamonds.
- A GIA Premium stone and an IGI stone: Premium lines up with an IGI report reading D, VVS2 or better, and Excellent. Compare it with IGI stones at that level, not with an IGI G VS2.
- A GIA Standard stone and an IGI stone: Standard covers D to J (usually E to J) and VS or better, so you can't line it up with one IGI grade. Ask the store for the stone's photos or video, and compare it with IGI stones across that range.
Whatever the lab, compare carat weight and cut first; they move the look and the price most. Our 4Cs guide explains each grade, and the lab-grown vs natural comparison covers price and resale.
Natural diamonds: nothing changed
GIA's change applies only to laboratory-grown diamonds. A natural diamond still gets a full GIA grading report: carat, color on the D-to-Z scale, clarity, cut on round brilliants, polish, symmetry and fluorescence. GIA is the long-standing reference for natural stones, and IGI grades natural diamonds on the 4Cs too. GIA plans, as reported in June 2026, to add a cut grade for ovals, pears and marquise shapes in 2027.
Checking a report
Both labs let you look up a report by its number on their own websites: GIA Report Check and IGI's Verify Your Report. Before you buy, check that the report number on the listing exists at the lab, that the carat weight and measurements match, and that the report says laboratory-grown for a lab-grown stone. A store that won't share the report number is a reason to shop elsewhere.
An in-house store report or appraisal is not an independent grade, whichever kind of diamond you buy. The certificate step of our buying guide covers the rest.
FAQ
Is a GIA "Premium" lab-grown diamond better than an IGI-graded one?
Not necessarily. Premium means the stone met GIA's top bar: D color, VVS clarity or better, and Excellent polish, symmetry and (on rounds) cut. An IGI report for a stone of that quality would say the same thing in letters, for example D, VVS1, Excellent. The difference is how much the report tells you, not the stone.
What does GIA "Standard" mean?
That the stone is at least J in color (usually E to J; a D stone that misses another Premium criterion is also Standard), at least VS in clarity, and at least Very Good in polish, symmetry and (on rounds) cut. It is a wide band: an E VVS2 and a J VS2 can both be Standard, and they are priced differently. An IGI report would tell them apart.
Did GIA stop grading lab-grown diamonds?
No. It still examines them, but since 1 October 2025 it describes the quality of colorless to near-colorless lab-grown stones as Premium or Standard instead of giving color and clarity grades, and a stone below Standard gets no GIA assessment. Colored lab-grown diamonds still get a separate GIA report. GIA reports issued before the change remain valid.
Does the change affect natural diamonds?
No. GIA's change applies to laboratory-grown diamonds. Natural diamonds are still graded on the full 4Cs.
Which report should I look for on a lab-grown ring?
Either is an independent report, which is what matters most. If you want to compare stones grade for grade, an IGI report gives you the exact color and clarity. A GIA Premium report tells you the stone is in the top band. Whichever you have, compare stones graded by the same lab.
Next steps
Sources
- GIA — Updated laboratory-grown diamond services to launch October 1 (26 August 2025; the Premium and Standard criteria, fee, inscription, and the quote from Pritesh Patel).
- GIA — New descriptive terminology for laboratory-grown diamonds (2 June 2025; the "more than 95%" figure; existing reports remain valid) and its laboratory-grown diamond services page (colorless to near-colorless stones of 0.15 carat and up; colored lab-grown reports).
- National Jeweler — GIA is changing its lab-grown diamond grading reports again (13 August 2020; grading since 2007; full color and clarity grades on digital-only reports from 2020).
- JCK — Lab-grown diamonds go mainstream (5 December 2025).
- IGI — sample Laboratory Grown Diamond Report (what an IGI lab-grown report lists: 4Cs, growth method, treatment, inscription).
- JCK — IGI's initial public offering (26 August 2024; IGI's 65% share of lab-grown grading reports).
- Modern Jeweler — GIA to launch a cut grade for select fancy shapes in 2027 (15 June 2026).